Quick answer: The Graveyard Keeper 2 twins, Heffry and Jeffry, live in Twins' Land, south of the village across the bridge. Their quest, Two Peas in a Pod, asks you to replace the pottery they lost: unlock Pottery I, build a Potter's Wheel, dig clay and make 6 Clay Plates (2 clay = 3 plates), then hand them over. The reward is a Basic Rod (your fishing rod), +5 village reputation and 1 Town Gratitude.
Spanish-speaking players search Graveyard Keeper 2 gemelos ("twins"); it's this quest. Two Peas in a Pod is the quest's name in your journal. It matters more than it looks: the twins row Jack's boat, and Jack's quest line is what opens the church and your main source of Faith.
Quick facts
- Quest: Two Peas in a Pod, after Supply and Demand
- Where: Twins' Land, south of the village across the bridge
- You need: 6 Clay Plates (4 clay is enough)
- Reward: Basic Rod, +5 village reputation, 1 Town Gratitude
- Leads to: Jack's boat, then the church
How to finish Two Peas in a Pod
Finish Supply and Demand
Two Peas in a Pod opens after that quest.
Find the twins
Cross the bridge south of the village. Talk to Heffry in Twins' Land, then find Jeffry near the Hangman's House and patch things up between them.
Unlock Pottery I and build a Potter's Wheel
Both are cheap. The wheel needs planks and Bronze Nails (Writing Desk explains where nails come from).
Dig clay and make 6 Clay Plates
Clay comes from dig spots. 2 Clay makes 3 plates. In a 100-day playthrough: "I have to bring six of them to these brothers to get a fishing rod."
Deliver the plates
You get the Basic Rod. Then keep going with Jack's boat.
After the twins: Jack's boat and the church
Build Jack's boat
Bring Jack 5 Wooden Planks and 5 Bronze Details.
Get the twins to row
When the boat is ready and the twins agree to row, Jack sets sail.
Meet the nun at the tavern
A few days later a nun arrives in the village. Talk to her at the tavern to open the church and sermons (Town Gratitude).
Don't treat Jack's boat as a side quest. A tips video warns that putting it off delays the church and its sermons, your steady source of Faith. Herbert asks for Faith early.
FAQ
The pottery quest brings it to 5. As of September 25, 2026 we haven't confirmed what gives the rest; the next step in their story is rowing Jack's boat.
Related
- Herbert: his Faith quest needs the church
- Town Gratitude: what sermons need
- Map: where the village and Twins' Land are
- Money: spare clay plates sell in bulk
Sources: a recorded 100% playthrough, a 100-day playthrough and a 7-tips guide on YouTube, Steam Community discussions, wikily.gg, Fextralife.